Monday, March 16, 2020

Thoughts on the Present Discontents


As suggested by the title, Burke’s ‘Thoughts on the Present Discontents’ comes to mind, but the circumstances are somewhat different in 2020 to 1770.  Edmund Burke was however concerned by the undue influence of the Crown on Parliament, and updated to our age one could possibly substitute ‘EU’ for ‘Crown’.  I have a number of Remainer friends who would object to this but, hey, tough.

‘Tell me one good thing the Coronavirus has done for us?’

Well, that’s easy; where shall I start?  The Duke of York perhaps?  Brexit?  Megxit?  There are quite a few folk who are delighted to be off the front pages for once.

But first, some advice for friends (they know who they are):

Given H’s recent chest problems you would be well advised to remain in your remote bolt hole in Great Elm (a tiny village not far from Frome for those who don’t know) and self-isolate (which is not far removed from self-immolate, though perhaps a more sensible response until we know if we are all ‘doomed, doomed, I tell you.’)

Sunday 15th March 2020
At the moment we have lounged around at home all day, though following the Government’s advice not to cancel ordinary events we attended the evening quiz night at the Royal Motor Yacht Club on Saturday.  Daughter Katie had announced her intention to visit this weekend and despite a rather dire service from South Western Railways (3 different trains; a bus replacement service from Southampton) she did make it as far as Bournemouth where I picked her up.  There usually has to be a reason for Katie visiting and the ulterior motive here was discussion of the ‘hen do’ for her close friend Katrina.  Not having a better offer on Saturday evening, she graciously accompanied us to the dinner and quiz, and her 90s and 2000s knowledge came in handy occasionally (Spice Girls a specialist subject), such that we came a respectable third, only one point behind the joint winners, which we thought not bad with only three on our team, whereas most other tables had six or more.  Generously, other friends who were on a table of 7 said we should have won, but that’s because they are fans of the Green Party and Proportional Representation.  Sadly, we knew that the friends who came first had a ringer, who knows everything about sport, including the one we failed as to the winner of the Grand National in 1967, when numerous horses were impeded or brought down, and a 100-1 odds horse won the race, having been in 22nd place at Becher’s Brook.  (I will leave you to look it up – clue: mountain in the North of Scotland).

At the moment, the Bournemouth Symphony Orchestra concert on Wednesday 18th is scheduled to go ahead.  Given the average age of the audience, a single corona infectee could probably cause as much carnage as that loose horse in 1967, though in that race only one horse was euthanised and the BSO audience might well be decimated.  (The concert hall holds 1500 people; you do the math as the Americans say).

Last week we also ventured to the cinema in Poole Lighthouse, to see the recorded ‘live’ performance of Cyrano de Bergerac, starring James McAvoy.  Now this is a play I love, having first seen it at the Oxford Playhouse in about 1966 (I can’t recall the cast – do you have the programme MJW?).  Then in 1971 the excellent and rarely revived 1950 black and white Hollywood film with Jose Ferrer (he won an Academy award for it, and the play benefited from some truncation in the movie), and then a superb (NT?) production with Anthony Sher in the late 1990s.  The Gerard Depardieu movie is also a fine interpretation.  When next I see the film (I will probably have the time given the current corona situation) I will have to try hard not to visualise Gerard urinating in the aisle on aeroplanes as he has been wont to do in recent years).  Cyrano is certainly a sentimental fin de siècle piece, but I suppose I’m a sucker for that.  So it was with some reluctance that I agreed to go to this ‘new’ punchy version.  Punchy it certainly is.  I don’t think I have heard so many f and c words since my summer job in the kitchens of the University Arms Hotel in Cambridge.  It is also somewhat bizarre to see costumes which smack of the present day, no swords in evidence, and a broad Glasgow-accented title character.  But the performance by McAvoy is astounding, a true tour de force.  To imitate the lisping pathetic estuary English of Christian and then to revert to original Glaswegian in the same breath has something of the touch of a great ventriloquist about it.  It’s a performance that like the original Jonathan Pryce Hamlet at the Royal Court I’m glad to say I was there.  Hardly unique though – these cinema relays go to thousands around the world.

With regard to the ‘current difficulties’ as one might refer to the coronavirus, events are sadly being cancelled right left and centre.  Whether this will prove a needless exercise or not time will prove.  Of one thing, I am now sure.  The rational and logical discussion with the South Korean health minister (Sunday morning) on the Andrew Marr show indicates that by forgetting pretty much about testing people in the UK, we are missing a trick.  For example, my daughter has a flatmate, a teacher who returned from a school ski trip to Italy, became unwell and was tested.  She and my daughter were told to stay at home in their flat.  It took a whole week before they gave her the all clear.  What a huge and stupid loss of productivity.  If people who become unwell are not being tested but just told to stay home, when the majority of them could be tested and then allowed to go back to work seems crazy.

There has been talk of contacting retired doctors to ask them to help.  Having not received any approach from the General Medical Council I wrote to them to volunteer.  With some ‘hauteur’ they replied to say they didn’t recognise my e mail address (although I had given them my unique 7 figure registration number) and were not sure if I was genuine, and in any case they had no plans to do anything unless the Government invoked the Extraordinary Powers Act.  I pointed out that they might have been more proactive in at least checking with retired doctors whether they might feel able to help if called upon.  No response as yet…

Having rambled on, I return to the main impetus for the above writing:
‘Arlott, Swanton and the Soul of English Cricket’ by Stephen Fay and David Kynaston.  A Christmas present, which I had been reading in desultory fashion, and now the second half finished in an afternoon when I had otherwise more probably been engrossed in the TPC Championship from Sawgrass, Florida.  A ‘worthy book’, one might say, damning with faint praise.  It’s a little bit dry and I suspect it is only a book which somebody of my age would want to read.  You needed to have heard the two title characters in full flow to get the most out of the book.  To imagine those Arlott phrases once again with that unforgettable Hampshire accent brings back such happy childhood memories.  I smiled occasionally, but laughed aloud only twice.  Will I spoil it for you if I quote the passages?  Perhaps, but then you might not read it anyway.

Patrick Collins (on Arlott):
Although he was a kind man, he didn’t suffer foolishness.  I asked him about a fellow commentator who once set out to emulate Arlott by injecting colour into a county match with some absurdly florid language.  Unfortunately it was always the same phrase.  For instance he’d say: ‘The bowler trudges back to his mark as the sun sets slowly in the West.’   Later: ‘And that single takes Somerset to 153 for 2, as the field changes, and the sun sets slowly in the West.’   And later still: ‘The Essex attack continues to struggle, and the sun sets slowly in the West.  Now, over to John Arlott.’  And Arlott took the microphone and announced: ‘The sun is still slowly setting in the West.  And if it should start to set anywhere else, I’ll be the first to let you know.’

And Arlott’s cruel rhetorical question (said only in private): ‘Can you imagine what it must be like to write as much as Swanton did over so many years without leaving one memorable sentence?’  … and some truth also in John Warr’s witty description of Swanton’s writing style as ‘somewhere between the Ten Commandments and Enid Blyton.’

Let me know if any of my readers would like the book.  I’ve probably done it down a little too much and given the reversion to reading which we are now all going to do (feels like back to the 1950s again, doesn’t it?), you may very probably wish to read it.  Were it not for the virus I would probably be donning shorts and popping out to the library, with my three tickets clutched firmly in my hand, for whatever the shelves could throw at me.  On one memorable occasion – I must have been about 12, I returned from the library with an Arthur Ransome, Isaac Asimov’s book on ‘The World of Carbon’, and an autobiographical work by Salvador Dali.  The reason I remember this was my mother’s horror on turning the pages of the Dali book.  There was a section I remember dealing with certain bodily secretions and his wife Gala…

As a parenthesis, Asimov once said he knew how to distinguish chemists from non-chemists: ask a person to pronounce the word ‘Unionized’.  You can work it out for yourself.

Although I now live in Branksome rather than ‘Lake Wobegon’ I think you get the drift of a diary from someone with not that much else to do…

No comments:

Post a Comment