Friday, November 20, 2026

The Evening Hill Diaries in Autumn 2026


October 2026

I recently attended the exhibition at Tate Modern entitled ‘Frida Kahlo- the Making of an Icon’, of which more later.

 

An early self portrait by Frida Kahlo

 

After the summer/autumn blog, an old friend wrote to me.  He mentioned the sad death of Ann Widdecombe and asked if I knew that her father was the head of the Admiralty (the employer of both of our parents)?  Indeed, I did.  He was a rather forbidding man called James Murray Widdecombe.  Eight years older than my father, he was of course, very senior.  The Admiralty had various subdivisions and sometime in the 1960s the name was changed to RNSTS (Royal Naval Supply and Transport Services).  ‘Widdy’, as my mother called him seemed austere and unwelcoming on the one occasion I met him at his home near Bath.  Rather than an informal welcome, my recollection is that we were ushered into his presence.  My father was probably being briefed on a subsequent posting, involving the Polaris naval base in Scotland.  I was in my mid-teens.  I think Ann was one of the Bath Convent girls that we used to meet after school at the Manvers Street bus station before wending our ways home.  (On reflection, given her devotion to her schoolwork, she may not have been one of the Manvers Street Irregulars).  Relations were, I’m sad to say, always very staid.  My impression of ‘Widdy’ is borne out by an interview I heard with Ann Widdecombe many years later – was it on Desert Island Discs?  She was in thrall to the perfectionist and demanding nature of her father, as I recall.  Hence her dedication to gaining the highest marks for homework, and her subsequent academic success.  Many will not know that as a girl, and at Oxford, she was something of a ‘stunner’ (I apologise if this is a sexist construction).

My friend mentioned that at Devonport High School for Boys (which he attended in the 1960s) the example of former pupil Mr Widdecombe (1910-1999) as someone who had ‘made it’ was regularly brought up.  He states: the assertion made was; ‘”So can you if you apply yourself”, in the preachy way our school used to do.’

But he also drew attention to a jazz star old boy, who is never mentioned by the school and does not feature in any of the PR he receives.  A hint, he felt, of what his old school admires.

 

It reminded me that my own school (well, at least one of the five that I attended – no I was not expelled!) is reluctant to mention that the odious Dr Andrew Wakefield (MMR scandal) was a former pupil.  They prefer to dwell on recent stars such as Bill Bailey (musician and comedian) and Max Ojomoh (rugby player).  They are very reluctant to divulge anything about Dr Wakefield from the archives.  I know; I asked the archivist in return for writing an article for them.  But there is evidence, attested in the medical journals, that early schooling, training, and early career behaviour is predictive of later wrongdoing.  I think the paper that examined this most rigorously was in the New England Journal of Medicine, some years ago.  Often the misdemeanours, for example, at Medical School, seemed minor at the time.

 

My interest in this topic was first stimulated by the fact that I had an unpleasant experience (not medical) early in my career at the hands of the late Rodney Ledward, FRCOG, a man who subsequently ruined the gynaecological organs of many women in the Ashford area of Kent.  It was a shock to open my newspaper many years later to find his face on the front page.  I thought, ‘I could have told them he was a bad egg years ago’, but I did not know any way of pursuing this.  Subsequently Ledward died of pancreatic cancer in Ireland, though the death was hushed up for a while.  At least one patient thought she recognised him some years after his reported death.  It led to a leader in the British Medical Journal entitled something like ‘First Elvis; now Ledward’.

One of the most obvious examples of early career misdemeanours is of course Dr Harold Shipman, the mass murderer, who in his career as a junior, took drugs and forged signatures for his prescriptions of opiates.  It seems likely that he was a murderer in Todmorden, Yorkshire, even before being reinstated in the Medical Register and moving to Hyde in Manchester.

Dr Andrew Wakefield was around 8 years behind me at my school in Bath, and it is probable that some of my teachers taught him.  I would have loved to garner their impressions of the young Wakefield.  His anti-vax stance has unfortunately made him the darling of the American Republicans (viz. Robert F Kennedy, Jr.) and I believe he now lives in the USA, and is doing very well, thank you.

 

Before leaving matters medical, I know, from conversations, and from letters in the press, that many doctors have been dismayed by the recent death of a young child from a ruptured appendix, which clearly could have been avoided.  He was seen in the emergency department by an ‘Advanced Nurse Practitioner’, and a diagnosis of ‘flu was made.  He was then discharged.  His mother related that the examiner had been wearing ‘scrubs’ and that they had assumed she was a doctor.

At the risk of reiterating what many others have said, when my generation of junior doctors saw such cases, they had usually been seen on a home visit after evening surgery by an experienced general practitioner who had telephone access directly to the house surgeon (i.e., me).  It was dinned into us that these doctors were more experienced than we were, and that we should accept them for admission.  Often the doctor would say something like, ‘Please tell your boss or your registrar that this is a “hot” one.’  This was Medspeak for a threatened burst appendix leading to peritonitis and risk of death.  Sometimes we operated most of the night on these cases.  Nowadays of course, GPs do not do home visits of this kind, which must be at least partly responsible for this recent tragedy.  Multiple other factors, such as pressure on beds, and the awful European Working Time Directive which limits the amount of time doctors can work, contribute too.

Parenthetically, you may wonder if this law pertains in other countries.  After a tragic incident some years ago in a US hospital after a prescription error from doctors working a 36-hours shift, the so-called ‘Libby’s Law’ was introduced.  Libby Zion died in 1984, and it took some years before an 80 hour per week restriction was imposed on a national basis.  This is almost double that of the EWTD.

It also led me on to think about the ‘scrubs’ epidemic.  In my day (sorry about the italics), scrub suits were pulled on because they were surgically clean and sterile, and only worn as one went into the operating theatre (the Operating Room or OR if you prefer the US designation).  I suspect that programmes from the USA such as ER did much to popularise the image of the healthcare professional wearing them.  But the original emphasis on cleanliness and sterility has disappeared – I have seen healthcare workers travelling to and from work in them, which surely defeats the purpose of scrubs as a sterile protection for the doctor and patient?  It also amuses me that stethoscopes are often worn by ancillary staff, a sort of pseudo badge of competence and trustworthiness.  The quality of many of these cheap stethoscopes is awful.

 

A final anecdote about acute appendicitis.  It was related by Dr William St C Symmers, a pathologist, in his book, ‘Curiosa’.  Unfortunately, this book is now very difficult to get hold of.  I read it as a medical student, and I haven’t seen a copy for very many years.

A surgical registrar was called by his junior to see a young lad with what the house surgeon thought was appendicitis.  The history given was that the little boy was ‘off colour’, off his food, and had some rather minor central abdominal pain.  His temperature was minimally elevated.  Then he was sick (vomited).  Within an hour or two, the pain appeared to have migrated to the right iliac fossa (the lower right area of the abdomen), and it was much more severe.  (The above description is a classic presentation of the evolution of acute appendicitis).  The child had a surgical appendicectomy scar immediately over the area of the pain.  The scar was small, neat, and had obviously been elegantly stitched – in fact it was hard to see.  But the localised pain over the area was intense, with ‘guarding’ (reflex withdrawal of abdominal muscle on touch), his temperature was higher, and he was clearly becoming very unwell.  The registrar rang the consultant.  They discussed the case and went over the development of symptoms several times.  The consultant declared himself puzzled.  ‘Are you sure he has had his appendix removed?’  He queried.  ‘Yes sir’, came the reply.  His mother said that Mr X performed the operation a couple of years ago.’

‘What did you say?’  Asked the consultant.

‘I said that Mr X performed appendicectomy two years ago, sir.’

‘Get the boy to theatre immediately’, was the response.  ‘I’m coming in.’

The patient was taken to theatre and a severely inflamed and infected appendix with impending rupture was removed.  The consultant explained that Mr X had been notorious for doing ‘cosmetic’ appendicectomies.  The skin was lightly incised; the abdomen was not opened. And the wound was carefully sewn up to cosmetic standards.  Many patients praised the speed of recovery and the marvellous scar healing…

An awful story, I think you may agree.

 

October 21st, 2026

Exactly 60 years after the Aberfan disaster.  After heavy rain, a coal tip (slag heap), the size of a small hill avalanched down on Pantglas school.  116 children and 28 adults died.  The Royal Family, en masse, attended services today.  I felt sure that they wanted to exorcise the inaction of Queen Elizabeth II, who, perhaps badly advised, left it some time before visiting the scene of the tragedy in 1966.

Whenever I hear mention of this, I cannot help thinking of a tiny footnote in this story.  A footnote which is likely to be forever buried (pardon the allusion):

 

The Welsh writer, Gwyn Thomas, dramatist, novelist, raconteur (1913-1981), was a witty chronicler of life in the mining valleys of South Wales.  His play ‘The Keep’ premiered at the Royal Court in 1962, with a young Ian McKellen (plus Colin Kaye, Josie Kidd, Gawn Grainger).  He wrote many articles, plays, novels, and contributed to Punch.  I was imbued with Welshness after the impressionable years aged 10 to 13 in West Wales, and our family followed Gwyn Thomas whenever he appeared on television or radio.  Among his plays, not even mentioned on Wikipedia, is one called ‘The Slip’.  It was shown in October 1962 on the BBC ‘Sunday Night Play’ series, and I watched it.  It featured a small cast of lugubrious and philosophical Welsh miners living in a fictional village on the edge of a ‘tip’.  Some of the discussion centred on the fact that many of the houses, and the local pub, were subject to sudden subsidence (hence the title).  The second act, which I remember as very daring because it showed three men, obviously in the pub urinal, face on, upper bodies and faces only, talking while relieving themselves.  As a 14-year-old, I thought the setting and the subject matter both daring and funny.  My mother thought it coarse and unnecessary which only added to my enjoyment and appreciation.  During this scene, periodically, the whole urinal gave a little lurch.  The characters had trouble deciding which was due to ‘The Slip’ or to inebriation.   They treated the slip as a normal consequence of living by a slag heap over a landscape riven by unseen tunnels and chambers.  After Aberfan, this play was quietly forgotten and will never be revived.  Comic fiction became sad and awful truth.

 

Gwyn Thomas came from the mining country.  Here is the introduction to his book, ‘A Welsh Eye’, published 1964, i.e. two years before the tragedy of Aberfan.  Prophetic, if you will:

‘…beyond the (river) Waun, the great barrier ridge that marks the southern limit of the Rhondda.  There is a deep hostile stare about that wall of grey and green.  These mountains do not like what has been done to them.  Too much has been taken from them.’

And…

‘Just behind our house was the vast tip built up from the endless honeycombing of pitwork beneath us.  The rattle of trams up and down the tip, through the day and notably through the night, clad each of our dreams in a cloak of sharp and cruel omens.’

‘In those days we did not notice the tip’s colour, its blasphemous lack of green.  The young are great acceptors and the tip, like the pit, was the centre of our world.  But grass of a sort grows over it now, a dim, grudging grass over the dramatic undulations, like a landscape of the moon.  The old tracks of the tramlines down its flank are a contracting, sardonic furrow.  The engine-house is now an empty shell upon its eminence.  The winds blow through it and the ferns creep back into their old kingdom.’

Gwyn Thomas deserves to be better known.  In fairness, he is greatly admired by Sir Anthony Hopkins, who was a family friend, and has done much to sustain his memory.

 

I say ‘imbued with Welshness’.  It is hard if you were not there to understand the degree of Welsh indoctrination we experienced, particularly in my part Welsh speaking primary school.  Who for instance has heard of the ‘Welsh Not’, the Rebecca riots, the Mabinogion, ‘hwyl’, the Landsker line, the dolmen of Pentre Ifan, the birth of Henry VII in Pembroke castle, anthracite, eisteddfodau, the last invasion of Britain in 1797 (in Pembrokeshire), Llangollen, Portmeirion, the ‘Gower’, St Govan’s chapel (the smallest chapel in Britain), Cardiff Arms Park?  Who now knows that in 1123, Pope Callixtus II declared that two pilgrimages to St David’s in Pembrokeshire was equivalent to one pilgrimage to Rome?  The dispensations and indulgences obtained for pilgrims (in return for money) subsidised the building of the cathedral of St David, primarily in the 12th and 13th centuries.  Even if we had not visited these places, anywhere outside Pembrokeshire being regarded as far-flung, or knew little about them, our Welsh-speaking teacher in primary school conveyed the notion that they were distant objects of wonder.

As a raconteur, in those dim, electronic-snow-bedecked black-and-white 405-line TV days, the occasional appearance of Gwyn Thomas was a joy.  He epitomised what Richard Burton meant, when asked why the local townsfolk and children were so effective in his film of ‘Under Milk Wood’, his answer was: ‘The Welsh are all actors; it’s only the bad ones who become professional.’  Those who have lived in rural Wales know this to be true, despite the Wildean epigram.

 

October 22nd and 23rd.

Storm Austen, the first of the season, bucketed its way through the South Coast last night and today.  In awful weather, we attended the Europa League game, AFC Bournemouth versus AC Milan.  The colours of the Rossoneri (red and blacks) were the original inspiration for the red and black shirts worn by our team.  But there was little else inspirational about them as they were soundly beaten by humble Bournemouth.  The most impressive thing to me was the general quality of the play, despite the torrential rain and high winds.

 

October 24th and 25th.

Following the storm, a huge maritime pine came down across Bingham Avenue, in the road we traverse every day.  It seems a miracle that no one was hurt.  When will the council accept that their addiction to the (non-native) pines which festoon our area need a serious risk-assessment and culling of many more trees that place lives and property at risk?

Pine fall in Bingham Avenue


 

Another storm – Bournemouth away at Manchester United.  The result: Manchester United 0 Bournemouth 3.

A great free kick against AC Milan



In the football picture above, it is almost impossible to gauge the severity of the rain.  Water is both translucent and transparent.  Contrast this with the solidity of hailstones (below) which photograph much better.  For a long time, there was a Hollywood myth that the rain features in Singin’ in the Rain were only filmed by adding milk to the ‘rain’.  Indeed, we were told this at the tour of Disney-MGM Studios many years ago.  ‘Singin’ in the Milk’ was how the tour guide described it.  It seems that this was not true, and the cinematic result was achieved by clever front and back uplighting against a dark background…

April hail, Crichel Mount Road


 

Sometime in the summer I saw a flyer which indicated that the organist, Anna Lapwood, would play and give an organ recital in St Peter’s Church, Parkstone.  Thinking this would be a niche event I booked two tickets, though Lindsay was away, and I attended with a friend who is a competent pianist.

 

We arrived early and found the queue already stretching from the church down into the centre of Lower Parkstone.  Having marked a couple of places, I was able to look around.  The average age of the audience was not too dissimilar to me, and clearly, Miss Lapwood was something of a phenomenon.  Surely this substantial audience, in excess of 400, could not all be here for a bit of Bach and Buxtehude?

Of course, I was wrong.  It seems that Anna, due to substantial exposure at the Proms and on Classic FM, is famous for her own arrangements of film themes.  She also projects a remarkable and attractive personality, with an infectious enthusiasm.  The cameras were set up to show the three manuals of the organ, so that the majority of the audience could watch her play as well as listen.  After each piece she literally bounced across the floor to the front of the church to introduce the next work.  ‘And after the interval’, she announced at the end of the first half, ‘It will be “The Lord of the Rings”’.  Cue roar of appreciation.

My friend and I decamped to the Bermuda Triangle pub across the road during the interval and were surprised that no-one else joined us.  But back we went, and Anna delivered.  Terrific stuff.  No Bach, at least not this time.  Aging groupies gathered at the end to chat and to get selfies.  As another friend of mine (who is a serious organist, having played in St Paul’s) told me later; ‘She’s made organ music cool.’

The irrepressible Anna Lapwood


I have posted another picture, for no other reason than I find it attractive.  It’s a fine painting.




For those who are struggling to identify the church, this is Duke University Chapel (Duke University, Durham, North Carolina), built in the early 1930s, and in Gothic style, but with no particular English church or cathedral in mind.  The superfluity of funds available to U.S. universities allowed them to commission, in the 1970s, the famous Dutch organ building firm of Flentrop to build a replica Baroque organ (the only concession to modern instruments was the electricity powering the air pump).  This was the last ever organ built by Dirk Flentrop before his retirement.  Looking it up recently, I was amazed to find that the chapel has in fact five playable organs.  I wondered whether it was a record.  It isn’t.  There are others with six, the most famous one being in Portugal.  But Duke also has a 50-bell carillon.  Its sound is easily found online.

 

Remembrance Day, Sunday November 8th, 2026

I wrote some of the above after listening to, and watching, the annual ceremony by the Cenotaph in Whitehall.  The sound of the bagpipes reminded me of a friend who is a piper.

 

Another tenuous link.  The Baroque organ mentioned above reminds me that I have just posted, using a corny pun, a selection of pictures of interiors in Prague entitled ‘If it ain’t Baroque, don’t post it.’  The pun obviously depends on using the American pronunciation of ‘Baroque’.  I always enjoy John McEnroe’s pronunciation of the Serbian tennis player Novak Djokovic as ‘Joke-a-vitch’ and it was this that I had in mind.

 

I had thought that the Abbey church of St Michael in Mondsee, near Salzburg, was ornate.  It features in the wedding scene from the Sound of Music.  It is a gothic church with baroque ornamentation.  The Prague churches all date from the spread of ‘Late Baroque’ throughout Europe.  The term ‘Baroque’ originally means ‘complicated’, and the churches of Prague seem to go all out to exemplify the designation.

 

Basilica of St James, Old Town, Prague

Church of St Nicholas, Prague.  Mozart played the organ in 1787 and his Mass in C received its first performance here.

State Opera House, Prague


 

I confess that our visit to Prague (somewhere I have always wanted to go) was due to the recent success of Bournemouth in finishing high enough up the Premier League table to get into one of the minnows’ European competitions (the Europa League).  The first away game was at Real Sociedad (San Sebastian) and the Bournemouth fans started a tradition of meeting in the centre of whichever location the team is playing and marching en masse to the football stadium.  Here in Prague, we were corralled (rather than kettled) by police with multiple members in riot gear and escorted to the ground.  After crossing the river Vlatava we ascended multiple steps into Letna park where we were met by additional police on horseback.  Bournemouth won 3-1.  We had been unable to get tickets in the first tranche and had to rely on our hotel concierge, so that we were sitting with the Sparta Prague fans.  There was silence all around us when Bournemouth scored their three goals, and though we missed the general delirium from the far-off caged corner where the AFCB fans were ‘prisoned we had a better view.

The now traditional march of AFC Bournemouth fans to the ground of Sparta Prague.  Crossing the Vlatava and ascending the steps to Letna park.

The Vlatava from Letna Park.  The Charles bridge is the second span upriver with the multiple arches.


 

Some of the other pictures below show that Prague is not all Baroque interiors.  David Czerny, acclaimed Czech sculptor, has many public works on display.  The most striking is his ‘Kafka Head’.  I have only shown a still image.  Every hour the head ‘metamorphoses’ in sections, rotating to form a head facing in a different direction.

Kafka's head - David Czerny

Another David Czerny.  Butterfly wings on Spitfire fuselage.

The original Tesla company.  They made radios.  Elon Musk had to buy the name.

The crypt of the church where the paratroopers who assassinated Reinhard Heydrich in 1942 held out.  A sombre museum.


 

Prague inevitably also has a large Ukrainian diaspora and is a strong supporter of the country.  They are only too aware of what happened to them in 1968.  Trams carry supportive messages, and all the child mascots at the football match were dressed in the Ukrainian colours.

 

 

Indicative of the Czech feeling about Ukraine.

 

After rather a long interval I return to Frida Kahlo.  Much of her at times stormy relationship with Diego Rivera (almost twice her age when they married) is better researched online than in an extended prĂ©cis from me.  The cynic in me thinks that marrying Rivera could be construed as a ‘good career move’ – he was already famous and it was his third marriage after their whirlwind affair.  But her fame and her ‘icon’ status results in part from her later adoption by feminists, LGBT etc and those who salute post-colonialism (Spanish, not British for a change) and ethnic or aboriginal movements.  Here is one more of her paintings, typical in its exoticism, and one of her many dresses utilizing national themes.  Her unashamed portrayal of her facial hair has of course been acclaimed by the feminist movement, another reason for the clamour of admiration.  A sobering poster at the very end of the exhibition points up of the ridiculous farce of an art market which discriminates against female painters:





 

An almost complete non sequitur, but walking back along the South Bank, I was struck by the similarity of the lamp standards to those in Poole.  They were designed by George Vulliamy in 1870 and originally placed on the Victoria and Albert embankments.  In 1977, to celebrate the Queen’s silver jubilee, more were placed on the south embankment, and this is probably one of those.  The theme of intertwined dolphins or sturgeons is derived from the Neptune fountain in the Piazza del Popolo in Rome (early 1820s).  The similar Poole lamp standards at Sandbanks were placed in 1895.



 

Although it is not the Christmas season yet, it is impossible to forget it, thanks to the tacky sentimentalism of the large stores’ seasonal adverts.  Politically it is a troubling time.  Our new Prime Minister is full of soundbites, but we await action.  President Trump, seemingly more deranged, has cosied up to Putin and Xi, and seems to ignore the blatant invasion of a neighbouring country (Ukraine) and the buildup of Chinese vessels around Taiwan.

 

So, to conclude on a brighter note.  I recommend the Renoir exhibition at the National Gallery annexe.  Renoir (1841-1919) did not start painting seriously until his 20s.  I had not realised how his style of painting changed.  At first influenced by, and contributing to, other Impressionists, after the age of 40 he felt that he had gone as far as he could with the Impressionist ideal and adopted a more realistic or neo-classical style.  He changed again later in life.  Here are two examples which I enjoyed from the exhibition, which includes works from all over the world, and must have taken a long time to plan and curate.  The first is a painting from his Impressionist period – the Seine at Bougival, painted in 1873.  This was loaned by the Milwaukee Art Museum.  The second is the very familiar Les Parapluies.  This painting shows his change in style in evolution.  He began the painting in about 1880 or 1881, with strongly Impressionistic characteristics.  The figure on the left represents the contrast, influenced by Ingres and the Italian paintings he had seen on a journey through Italy.  It is painted in his later realistic style.  I confess that despite seeing this on several occasions in the National Gallery I had not noticed the subtle differences between the two sides of the picture.

Renoir, 1873

Renoir, 1881
You learn something every day…

 


All good wishes for the upcoming season.

Poole Harbour.  An Autumn au revoir.



Andrew